Richard Levick | April 2nd, 2019
Boeing Meets Thomas Hobbes On the Way To AI

In interviews and coverage this week with The New York Times, Korea™’s Chosun, CBS Radio, and O’Dwyer™’s, all of the reporters expertly covered Boeing™’s crisis response. The larger conversations were, to me, more interesting.
Great tragedies bear great lessons or we dishonor the dead and our own capacity for growth. If we are fortunate enough to have lost no one on either Lion Air or Ethiopian Air; if we are not a Boeing employee, we have enough distance to grow without the pain of loss. For anyone at the epicenter of a crisis response, time travels at quantum speed, simultaneously both too fast for certainty and so slow that you can see each moment as if in a movie. It is not an experience for those fearful of decisions and their consequences.
Do not walk too fast past this tragedy or we will miss the lessons for our own coming challenges in this disrupted age. As you can see from Boeing™’s improving response, they are learning quickly:
- Business-to-Business communications no longer exists. That form of communications where you could name all of your customers, like Takada, GS Yuasa, and Foxconn, is gone. We are all consumer brands now. No one is talking about how Ethiopian Air trains its pilots. It™’s all Boeing, all the time. Boeing is no more a business brand any more than Apple is. If you still think B-to-B than your day of reckoning is soon to come.
- The last war In not the next war. Generals always look backwards to see forwards but sometimes forget to crane their necks. Boeing learned wise lessons from the four crashes of their then-new 727s in the mid-1960s as they did from the two DC 10s that crashed in 1970s by now-acquired McDonnell Douglas. Both would become highly popular planes. Boeing learned to focus on the long view. But the longer perspective, which will ultimately serve Boeing well, inhibited them in the opening hours and days of the crisis. History is a great teacher, but there are always exceptions.
- The FAA has lost its global dominance. Whether due to the result of nationalistic trends or disruption, the FAA no longer dominates global aviation safety decisions. This is problematic for Boeing, which has spent a half century integrating itself into the FAA regulatory apparatus. Their $40 billion market value drop – when the total cost of recovery is estimated at $5 billion – is at least, in part, a recognition of this seismic shift. How many companies are re-thinking their public affairs strategy in its entirety?
- Social media have made all crashes (and incidents) local. Few doubt that the FAA would have grounded the Max 8 if the crashes had occurred in the US. What the FAA and Boeing failed to initially appreciate is that social media have made all crashes local. This works both ways. When United Airlines forcibly dragged Dr. Dao off their plane at O’Hare two years ago, the video was download 20 million times per hour in China. Tip O’Neill™’s advice that “all politics is local†now resonates for business, even B-to-B businesses.
- The safety choice was democratized. When the travel site Kayak.com offered passengers a choice of opting out of a Max 8, for the first time it gave the power to air travelers to choose flights not just on price, location, and time but on their perception of the safety of an airplane. This quickly escalated to the de facto grounding of the Max 8 by the public, not by the FAA, Boeing, or the President.
All air plane crashes are news. This one will mark the moment at which we understand part of the price of AI and how it is inseparably connected to the price of the Hobbesian bargain. Democracy is voluntary. In exchange for a constitutional form of government (where we have the power to “throw the rascals outâ€) we voluntarily turn over decisions to experts – aviation, medicine, regulation, etc. Increasingly, shareholders and non-shareholders alike are asking the question, “How expert are the experts?†And therefore, “At what cost do we turn over decisions to experts in exchange for order?†Civilians on social media are in no position to determine the airworthiness of a new plane. But for a while, we are going to think we are.
New York Times- Dealbook BriefingÂ
New York Times- “As Boeing Confronted a Swelling Crisis, It Had Little to Say”
O’Dwyer’s- “Sard Verbinnen Flies to Boeing Crisis Support”
Richard Levick | April 2nd, 2019
Boeing Meets Thomas Hobbes On the Way To AI

In interviews and coverage this week with The New York Times, Korea™’s Chosun, CBS Radio, and O’Dwyer™’s, all of the reporters expertly covered Boeing™’s crisis response. The larger conversations were, to me, more interesting.
Great tragedies bear great lessons or we dishonor the dead and our own capacity for growth. If we are fortunate enough to have lost no one on either Lion Air or Ethiopian Air; if we are not a Boeing employee, we have enough distance to grow without the pain of loss. For anyone at the epicenter of a crisis response, time travels at quantum speed, simultaneously both too fast for certainty and so slow that you can see each moment as if in a movie. It is not an experience for those fearful of decisions and their consequences.
Do not walk too fast past this tragedy or we will miss the lessons for our own coming challenges in this disrupted age. As you can see from Boeing™’s improving response, they are learning quickly:
- Business-to-Business communications no longer exists. That form of communications where you could name all of your customers, like Takada, GS Yuasa, and Foxconn, is gone. We are all consumer brands now. No one is talking about how Ethiopian Air trains its pilots. It™’s all Boeing, all the time. Boeing is no more a business brand any more than Apple is. If you still think B-to-B than your day of reckoning is soon to come.
- The last war In not the next war. Generals always look backwards to see forwards but sometimes forget to crane their necks. Boeing learned wise lessons from the four crashes of their then-new 727s in the mid-1960s as they did from the two DC 10s that crashed in 1970s by now-acquired McDonnell Douglas. Both would become highly popular planes. Boeing learned to focus on the long view. But the longer perspective, which will ultimately serve Boeing well, inhibited them in the opening hours and days of the crisis. History is a great teacher, but there are always exceptions.
- The FAA has lost its global dominance. Whether due to the result of nationalistic trends or disruption, the FAA no longer dominates global aviation safety decisions. This is problematic for Boeing, which has spent a half century integrating itself into the FAA regulatory apparatus. Their $40 billion market value drop – when the total cost of recovery is estimated at $5 billion – is at least, in part, a recognition of this seismic shift. How many companies are re-thinking their public affairs strategy in its entirety?
- Social media have made all crashes (and incidents) local. Few doubt that the FAA would have grounded the Max 8 if the crashes had occurred in the US. What the FAA and Boeing failed to initially appreciate is that social media have made all crashes local. This works both ways. When United Airlines forcibly dragged Dr. Dao off their plane at O’Hare two years ago, the video was download 20 million times per hour in China. Tip O’Neill™’s advice that “all politics is local†now resonates for business, even B-to-B businesses.
- The safety choice was democratized. When the travel site Kayak.com offered passengers a choice of opting out of a Max 8, for the first time it gave the power to air travelers to choose flights not just on price, location, and time but on their perception of the safety of an airplane. This quickly escalated to the de facto grounding of the Max 8 by the public, not by the FAA, Boeing, or the President.
All air plane crashes are news. This one will mark the moment at which we understand part of the price of AI and how it is inseparably connected to the price of the Hobbesian bargain. Democracy is voluntary. In exchange for a constitutional form of government (where we have the power to “throw the rascals outâ€) we voluntarily turn over decisions to experts – aviation, medicine, regulation, etc. Increasingly, shareholders and non-shareholders alike are asking the question, “How expert are the experts?†And therefore, “At what cost do we turn over decisions to experts in exchange for order?†Civilians on social media are in no position to determine the airworthiness of a new plane. But for a while, we are going to think we are.
New York Times- Dealbook BriefingÂ
New York Times- “As Boeing Confronted a Swelling Crisis, It Had Little to Say”
O’Dwyer’s- “Sard Verbinnen Flies to Boeing Crisis Support”
- Brand
- The Fifth Estate: A Business Guide for Surviving “The Troubles”
- Here We Come
- Corporate Revolt Over Campaign Donations Shakes Political World
- What Happens Next?
- CSR & Sustainability
- Public Perception & the Biden Transition
- WATCH: Reputation Management with PRSA
- Over the River and Through The Woods
- Why Non-Profits are so Vulnerable to Crisis Risk
- The Threat to Free Markets
- What Happens When Nonprofits Get Caught In The Klieg Lights?
- You Took a PPP Loan. Now Get Ready to Talk About It.
- Communications
- “Crooked Dominion Machines,” Impeachments, Insurrections & The First 100 Days
- Reflections on a Turbulent Year: 2020
- The Fifth Estate: A Business Guide for Surviving “The Troubles”
- Here We Come
- The Ministry of Common Sense
- Why Should I Apologize? Lawyers vs. Communicators
- What Happens Next?
- CSR & Sustainability
- A Conversation with Abbe Lowell
- A New Year’s Resolution
- Public Perception & the Biden Transition
- WATCH: Reputation Management with PRSA
- Company News
- Reflections on a Turbulent Year: 2020
- Here We Come
- Recent Awards & Recognition
- Won’t You Be My Neighbor?
- What’s a Director to Do?
- LEVICK Announces Partnership with BCG
- A New Look
- Albert Krieger, 1923-2020
- LEVICK Announces Partnership with Jipyong
- Speaking to In-House Counsel
- Childhood Lessons
- LEVICK Announces New Webinar Series with Turbine Labs
- Crisis
- “Crooked Dominion Machines,” Impeachments, Insurrections & The First 100 Days
- Reflections on a Turbulent Year: 2020
- 3 Tech Lessons Businesses Must Learn From COVID-19
- Trump’s pardons undercut a decade of foreign lobbying law enforcement. What now?
- Fighting for the Rule of Law with Marshall Harris
- The Fifth Estate: A Business Guide for Surviving “The Troubles”
- What to expect as the clock approaches midnight
- How to Stop the Madness
- Corporate Revolt Over Campaign Donations Shakes Political World
- A Remembrance of Tommy Raskin
- No ‘justice’ in rep’s vote
- A Call for Orderly & Peaceful Transition of Power
- Finance
- Here We Come
- The Threat to Free Markets
- Advisory & Insurance Services
- WATCH: Revolutionizing Litigation Finance
- Litigation Finance: Revolutionizing Litigation
- Consumer-Focused Solutions for Financial Health
- Event: Consumer-Focused Solutions for Financial Health
- Sports: Power and Money in a New Age of Social Justice
- The Balancing Act: The Role of Whistleblowers in American Commerce and Government
- The Evolving and More Powerful FARA
- FCPA & Compliance in a Time of Uncertainty
- Shareholders vs. Stakeholders: Is the Paradigm Shifting?
- Guest Column
- Guest Blog: The Mainstream Media Gets an A for Intellectual Arrogance, an F for Journalism
- Buckle up Directors: Cybersecurity Risk and Bankruptcy Risk Are Not Mutually Exclusive
- Buckle up Directors: Cybersecurity Risk and Bankruptcy Risk Are Not Mutually Exclusive
- South Africa: The Slow Decline of the ANC
- Why CSR Fails and How to Fix It
- What to Expect Following the European Elections?
- Buhari Inaugurated. What Now for Nigeria?
- Marketing- It’s Up To You…
- Crisis Management lessons from the air-crash investigation model
- The Future of War
- Health
- Reflections on a Turbulent Year: 2020
- Food Issues & the Biden Administration
- Covid-19: The Pandemic that Never Should Have Happened
- Pharma’s Post-Pandemic Policy Outlook
- Keeping Hope Alive
- Real Herd Immunity
- The Fiction of College Sports Amateurism
- Mac Summit: Crisis Communications in a Post-Covid, Post-Election World
- Travel Industry Communications in the Age of Covid-19
- Track of Time
- Is C-19 Taking Women Lawyers’ Careers Back to the 1950s?
- Post-Pandemic PR Strategy
- In Memoriam
- Snider’s Super Foods: Locally World Famous
- Speak Truth With Love, Not Anger
- In Memoriam: Stephen Susman
- Letter to the Movement
- John Lewis’ Life Bridged the Best of America
- Albert Krieger, 1923-2020
- In Memoriam of Marcia Horowitz
- Jim Lehrer Passes Away
- Martin Luther King, Jr.
- Harold Burson Passes Away
- Interviews
- CommPRO: Ruth Bader Ginsberg’s Life & Legacy
- Richard Levick on “My Wakeup Call”
- Primerus Webinar: Into the Wind
- The Future of Baseball Post-Pandemic
- Webinar: The End of Brand Neutrality
- Thought Leadership & Organic Growth
- Man & Superman
- LEVICK Announces New Webinar Series with Turbine Labs
- Navigating Coronavirus Challenges in the Insurance Industry
- VIDEO: How to Anticipate & Avoid a Crisis
- What’s Next? with Julie Chase
- What’s Next?: California Electoral Behavior
- Law Firms
- Fighting for the Rule of Law with Marshall Harris
- Why Should I Apologize? Lawyers vs. Communicators
- You Took a PPP Loan. Now Get Ready to Talk About It.
- Beyond Black Swan: Positioning the law firm for the new normal
- A Salute to Personal Courage and the Rule of Law
- Cyber Risk Institute Expands Its Profile
- When a client becomes a law firm’s PR nightmare
- The General Counsel’s Dilemma
- A First Look at the Google Antitrust Suit
- The Latest Top Class Actions
- Trust on Trial: How Communicators Succeed in a World No Longer Trusted
- The Latest Settlements, Class actions, Investigations & More
- Litigation
- Fighting for the Rule of Law with Marshall Harris
- Why Should I Apologize? Lawyers vs. Communicators
- A Conversation with Abbe Lowell
- Leveraging Legal Expertise in Communications
- You Took a PPP Loan. Now Get Ready to Talk About It.
- Beyond Black Swan: Positioning the law firm for the new normal
- A Salute to Personal Courage and the Rule of Law
- Cyber Risk Institute Expands Its Profile
- When a client becomes a law firm’s PR nightmare
- The General Counsel’s Dilemma
- WATCH: Revolutionizing Litigation Finance
- Litigation Finance: Revolutionizing Litigation
- Our Work
- Recent Awards & Recognition
- The Cyber Bad Guys Are Getting Worse
- Crisis Communications & The Age of Cancel Culture
- Standing on the Shoulders of Giants
- Video: Conversations with American Legends
- Staying Ahead of the Crisis
- A New Era of Insurance Marketing
- Infographic: Judgment Free Zone
- Infographic: Barriers to Entry
- Infographic: History Meter
- Assistance for Law Firms Engaged in Pro Bono
- Webinar: The End of Brand Neutrality
- Public Affairs
- “Crooked Dominion Machines,” Impeachments, Insurrections & The First 100 Days
- Trump’s pardons undercut a decade of foreign lobbying law enforcement. What now?
- Fighting for the Rule of Law with Marshall Harris
- The Fifth Estate: A Business Guide for Surviving “The Troubles”
- What to expect as the clock approaches midnight
- How to Stop the Madness
- Corporate Revolt Over Campaign Donations Shakes Political World
- No ‘justice’ in rep’s vote
- A Call for Orderly & Peaceful Transition of Power
- Recovering from the Greatest Sacrifice
- Food Issues & the Biden Administration
- The Cost of Government Regulation and the Threat to Free Enterprise
- Risk
- Ingredients of Decency
- ESG Performance and Credit Markets
- The Coronavirus Saga is Just Beginning
- No. 1 Risk of the Decade
- The Risk Evolution of Corporate Risk
- Extend Risk Management Reach
- Collective Action
- Risk Identifying Software
- The New Risk of Doing Nothing
- Political Unrest In Hong Kong
- High-Profile Kidnaps in African National Parks
- Cyber Resilience
- Social
- The Ministry of Common Sense
- How to Stop the Madness
- A Remembrance of Tommy Raskin
- No ‘justice’ in rep’s vote
- A Call for Orderly & Peaceful Transition of Power
- Recovering from the Greatest Sacrifice
- CSR & Sustainability
- A New Year’s Resolution
- Dropping the Mic
- Won’t You Be My Neighbor?
- Crisis, Covid, DEI & the Election
- MLK’s Memphis Address
- Technology
- 3 Tech Lessons Businesses Must Learn From COVID-19
- Constella Intelligence Announces Hunter for Improved Investigation Capability
- Cyber Risk Institute Expands Its Profile
- Digital Politics: The Future of Voting Technology
- Ethics in Electronics
- The Cyber Bad Guys Are Getting Worse
- A First Look at the Google Antitrust Suit
- The Pause
- Cybersecurity Incidents of the Summer
- The Changing Digital Economy and Cyber Risks
- The Future of U.S. Manufacturing
- Tech CEO Summer Superbowl hearing
- This Week
- A Remembrance of Tommy Raskin
- A New Year’s Resolution
- Over the River and Through The Woods
- Dropping the Mic
- Won’t You Be My Neighbor?
- The Cyber Bad Guys Are Getting Worse
- What We Hear
- Track of Time
- Video: Conversations with American Legends
- Conversations with American Legends
- A New Era of Insurance Marketing
- American Legend