Jack Deschauer | June 20th, 2016
Baylor and Starr Learn the Value of Proactive Crisis Planning

Anticipation, preparation, and training. All three are integral components of crisis management strategy that Baylor and its former President Ken Starr overlooked before the release of an investigation into the university™’s incredibly callous and most likely illegal handling of sexual assault allegations. The failings of Starr and the Baylor Board of Regents will cause lasting damage to the university™’s brand; it could take decades to restore its now tarnished reputation. While the legal ramifications of ensuing lawsuits and hefty settlements will be detrimental, the most destruction to Baylor will come in the court of public opinion. And nothing the school can do will ever erase the public™’s remembrance of the awful way they treated the victims – and nothing should.
Over the next few years, Baylor will be exposed to NCAA investigations truncating athletics, the potential withholding of federal funding, declining alumni donations, and a weakened pitch for prospective students.
This is not the first Baylor crisis to receive national attention. In 2003, a member of the men™’s basketball shot and killed a teammate. The subsequent NCAA investigation revealed that coaches had been providing improper cash benefits to athletes and that a rampant drug abuse problem existed among the basketball team. The revelations of the investigation alone should have revealed to Baylor the value of proactive crisis management. Apparently, they never got the message.
Before a crisis event hits, an institution the size of Baylor and a president with the notoriety of Starr should have top-notch crisis planners working on a proactive blueprint for the worst case scenario. Starr™’s decision to choose Merrie Spaeth as his PR representative only after the crisis spun out of control was a reactive move that led to a series of gaffs in a now viral KWTX interview.
Spaeth seemingly failed her client with a lack of interview preparation, which would have helped polish answers for predictable “gotcha†questions. Starr was guaranteed to be asked if he ever received the well-documented email from a former rape victim alerting the Baylor administration to the incident. Yet, when the question was asked, Starr first flubbed his answer, leading Spaeth to intervene and counsel him off camera before he returned to answer it with a vague and unconvincing, “I have no recollection.†For Starr, who stepped down from his role with the University for the express purpose of being open and honest with the public, the entire series comes across as insincere.
Starr had two choices: either provide an honest, clear, and concise answer to the reporter™’s question, or do not conduct the interview. Instead, the “easy layup†of granting an interview to a hand-picked outlet never made it in the basket. Lack of preparation for a predictable question – one any journalist with integrity would have asked – resulted in even worse press for the former president and the institution.
Proper interview preparation could have equipped Starr for the rape email question, but more alarming is his apparent lack of understanding of the overall media landscape. The worst moment came during a tone-deaf Outside The Lines interview where Starr praises former football coach Art Briles as a “father figure.† Starr should understand the media implication of complimenting Briles’ off-the-field character, given the former coach is at the center of a sexual assault cover-up investigation.
Starr™’s self-inflicted media fiasco should serve as a lesson for other universities about the value of proactive crisis management and transparent communication. Preemptive strategizing, with the help of the right communicators, will always be more effective than improvising on the fly. This time, in a scenario that could have been predicted by those astute enough to plan for the worst case scenario, both Starr and Baylor failed the test.
Silas Hill contributed to this post.Â
Jack Deschauer | June 20th, 2016
Baylor and Starr Learn the Value of Proactive Crisis Planning

Anticipation, preparation, and training. All three are integral components of crisis management strategy that Baylor and its former President Ken Starr overlooked before the release of an investigation into the university™’s incredibly callous and most likely illegal handling of sexual assault allegations. The failings of Starr and the Baylor Board of Regents will cause lasting damage to the university™’s brand; it could take decades to restore its now tarnished reputation. While the legal ramifications of ensuing lawsuits and hefty settlements will be detrimental, the most destruction to Baylor will come in the court of public opinion. And nothing the school can do will ever erase the public™’s remembrance of the awful way they treated the victims – and nothing should.
Over the next few years, Baylor will be exposed to NCAA investigations truncating athletics, the potential withholding of federal funding, declining alumni donations, and a weakened pitch for prospective students.
This is not the first Baylor crisis to receive national attention. In 2003, a member of the men™’s basketball shot and killed a teammate. The subsequent NCAA investigation revealed that coaches had been providing improper cash benefits to athletes and that a rampant drug abuse problem existed among the basketball team. The revelations of the investigation alone should have revealed to Baylor the value of proactive crisis management. Apparently, they never got the message.
Before a crisis event hits, an institution the size of Baylor and a president with the notoriety of Starr should have top-notch crisis planners working on a proactive blueprint for the worst case scenario. Starr™’s decision to choose Merrie Spaeth as his PR representative only after the crisis spun out of control was a reactive move that led to a series of gaffs in a now viral KWTX interview.
Spaeth seemingly failed her client with a lack of interview preparation, which would have helped polish answers for predictable “gotcha†questions. Starr was guaranteed to be asked if he ever received the well-documented email from a former rape victim alerting the Baylor administration to the incident. Yet, when the question was asked, Starr first flubbed his answer, leading Spaeth to intervene and counsel him off camera before he returned to answer it with a vague and unconvincing, “I have no recollection.†For Starr, who stepped down from his role with the University for the express purpose of being open and honest with the public, the entire series comes across as insincere.
Starr had two choices: either provide an honest, clear, and concise answer to the reporter™’s question, or do not conduct the interview. Instead, the “easy layup†of granting an interview to a hand-picked outlet never made it in the basket. Lack of preparation for a predictable question – one any journalist with integrity would have asked – resulted in even worse press for the former president and the institution.
Proper interview preparation could have equipped Starr for the rape email question, but more alarming is his apparent lack of understanding of the overall media landscape. The worst moment came during a tone-deaf Outside The Lines interview where Starr praises former football coach Art Briles as a “father figure.† Starr should understand the media implication of complimenting Briles’ off-the-field character, given the former coach is at the center of a sexual assault cover-up investigation.
Starr™’s self-inflicted media fiasco should serve as a lesson for other universities about the value of proactive crisis management and transparent communication. Preemptive strategizing, with the help of the right communicators, will always be more effective than improvising on the fly. This time, in a scenario that could have been predicted by those astute enough to plan for the worst case scenario, both Starr and Baylor failed the test.
Silas Hill contributed to this post.Â
- Brand
- Corporate Revolt Over Campaign Donations Shakes Political World
- What Happens Next?
- CSR & Sustainability
- Public Perception & the Biden Transition
- WATCH: Reputation Management with PRSA
- Over the River and Through The Woods
- Why Non-Profits are so Vulnerable to Crisis Risk
- The Threat to Free Markets
- What Happens When Nonprofits Get Caught In The Klieg Lights?
- You Took a PPP Loan. Now Get Ready to Talk About It.
- Avoid Future Shock: 10 Changes to Anticipate for 2021
- Guidance for Corporate Reputation Risk
- Communications
- Why Should I Apologize? Lawyers vs. Communicators
- What Happens Next?
- CSR & Sustainability
- A Conversation with Abbe Lowell
- A New Year’s Resolution
- Public Perception & the Biden Transition
- WATCH: Reputation Management with PRSA
- Leveraging Legal Expertise in Communications
- Over the River and Through The Woods
- Why Non-Profits are so Vulnerable to Crisis Risk
- The Threat to Free Markets
- Dropping the Mic
- Company News
- Recent Awards & Recognition
- Won’t You Be My Neighbor?
- What’s a Director to Do?
- LEVICK Announces Partnership with BCG
- A New Look
- Albert Krieger, 1923-2020
- LEVICK Announces Partnership with Jipyong
- Speaking to In-House Counsel
- Childhood Lessons
- LEVICK Announces New Webinar Series with Turbine Labs
- LEVICK Launches New Website
- LEVICK to Launch Podcast
- Crisis
- What to expect as the clock approaches midnight
- How to Stop the Madness
- Corporate Revolt Over Campaign Donations Shakes Political World
- A Remembrance of Tommy Raskin
- No ‘justice’ in rep’s vote
- A Call for Orderly & Peaceful Transition of Power
- Recovering from the Greatest Sacrifice
- The Cost of Government Regulation and the Threat to Free Enterprise
- What Happens Next?
- A Conversation with Abbe Lowell
- Covid-19: The Pandemic that Never Should Have Happened
- Public Perception & the Biden Transition
- Finance
- The Threat to Free Markets
- Advisory & Insurance Services
- WATCH: Revolutionizing Litigation Finance
- Litigation Finance: Revolutionizing Litigation
- Consumer-Focused Solutions for Financial Health
- Event: Consumer-Focused Solutions for Financial Health
- Sports: Power and Money in a New Age of Social Justice
- The Balancing Act: The Role of Whistleblowers in American Commerce and Government
- The Evolving and More Powerful FARA
- FCPA & Compliance in a Time of Uncertainty
- Shareholders vs. Stakeholders: Is the Paradigm Shifting?
- CommPRO: Transparent Political Donations
- Guest Column
- Guest Blog: The Mainstream Media Gets an A for Intellectual Arrogance, an F for Journalism
- Buckle up Directors: Cybersecurity Risk and Bankruptcy Risk Are Not Mutually Exclusive
- Buckle up Directors: Cybersecurity Risk and Bankruptcy Risk Are Not Mutually Exclusive
- South Africa: The Slow Decline of the ANC
- Why CSR Fails and How to Fix It
- What to Expect Following the European Elections?
- Buhari Inaugurated. What Now for Nigeria?
- Marketing- It’s Up To You…
- Crisis Management lessons from the air-crash investigation model
- The Future of War
- Health
- Food Issues & the Biden Administration
- Covid-19: The Pandemic that Never Should Have Happened
- Pharma’s Post-Pandemic Policy Outlook
- Keeping Hope Alive
- Real Herd Immunity
- The Fiction of College Sports Amateurism
- Mac Summit: Crisis Communications in a Post-Covid, Post-Election World
- Travel Industry Communications in the Age of Covid-19
- Track of Time
- Is C-19 Taking Women Lawyers’ Careers Back to the 1950s?
- Post-Pandemic PR Strategy
- Bankruptcy: A Culture of Transparency
- In Memoriam
- Snider’s Super Foods: Locally World Famous
- Speak Truth With Love, Not Anger
- In Memoriam: Stephen Susman
- Letter to the Movement
- John Lewis’ Life Bridged the Best of America
- Albert Krieger, 1923-2020
- In Memoriam of Marcia Horowitz
- Jim Lehrer Passes Away
- Martin Luther King, Jr.
- Harold Burson Passes Away
- Interviews
- CommPRO: Ruth Bader Ginsberg’s Life & Legacy
- Richard Levick on “My Wakeup Call”
- Primerus Webinar: Into the Wind
- The Future of Baseball Post-Pandemic
- Webinar: The End of Brand Neutrality
- Thought Leadership & Organic Growth
- Man & Superman
- LEVICK Announces New Webinar Series with Turbine Labs
- Navigating Coronavirus Challenges in the Insurance Industry
- VIDEO: How to Anticipate & Avoid a Crisis
- What’s Next? with Julie Chase
- What’s Next?: California Electoral Behavior
- Law Firms
- Why Should I Apologize? Lawyers vs. Communicators
- You Took a PPP Loan. Now Get Ready to Talk About It.
- Beyond Black Swan: Positioning the law firm for the new normal
- A Salute to Personal Courage and the Rule of Law
- Cyber Risk Institute Expands Its Profile
- When a client becomes a law firm’s PR nightmare
- The General Counsel’s Dilemma
- A First Look at the Google Antitrust Suit
- The Latest Top Class Actions
- Trust on Trial: How Communicators Succeed in a World No Longer Trusted
- The Latest Settlements, Class actions, Investigations & More
- Managing Legal & Communication Advice in a Crisis
- Litigation
- Why Should I Apologize? Lawyers vs. Communicators
- A Conversation with Abbe Lowell
- Leveraging Legal Expertise in Communications
- You Took a PPP Loan. Now Get Ready to Talk About It.
- Beyond Black Swan: Positioning the law firm for the new normal
- A Salute to Personal Courage and the Rule of Law
- Cyber Risk Institute Expands Its Profile
- When a client becomes a law firm’s PR nightmare
- The General Counsel’s Dilemma
- WATCH: Revolutionizing Litigation Finance
- Litigation Finance: Revolutionizing Litigation
- A First Look at the Google Antitrust Suit
- Our Work
- Recent Awards & Recognition
- The Cyber Bad Guys Are Getting Worse
- Crisis Communications & The Age of Cancel Culture
- Standing on the Shoulders of Giants
- Video: Conversations with American Legends
- Staying Ahead of the Crisis
- A New Era of Insurance Marketing
- Infographic: Judgment Free Zone
- Infographic: Barriers to Entry
- Infographic: History Meter
- Assistance for Law Firms Engaged in Pro Bono
- Webinar: The End of Brand Neutrality
- Public Affairs
- What to expect as the clock approaches midnight
- How to Stop the Madness
- Corporate Revolt Over Campaign Donations Shakes Political World
- No ‘justice’ in rep’s vote
- A Call for Orderly & Peaceful Transition of Power
- Recovering from the Greatest Sacrifice
- Food Issues & the Biden Administration
- The Cost of Government Regulation and the Threat to Free Enterprise
- What Happens Next?
- CSR & Sustainability
- A Conversation with Abbe Lowell
- Public Perception & the Biden Transition
- Risk
- Ingredients of Decency
- ESG Performance and Credit Markets
- The Coronavirus Saga is Just Beginning
- No. 1 Risk of the Decade
- The Risk Evolution of Corporate Risk
- Extend Risk Management Reach
- Collective Action
- Risk Identifying Software
- The New Risk of Doing Nothing
- Political Unrest In Hong Kong
- High-Profile Kidnaps in African National Parks
- Cyber Resilience
- Social
- How to Stop the Madness
- A Remembrance of Tommy Raskin
- No ‘justice’ in rep’s vote
- A Call for Orderly & Peaceful Transition of Power
- Recovering from the Greatest Sacrifice
- CSR & Sustainability
- A New Year’s Resolution
- Dropping the Mic
- Won’t You Be My Neighbor?
- Crisis, Covid, DEI & the Election
- MLK’s Memphis Address
- The Fiction of College Sports Amateurism
- Technology
- Constella Intelligence Announces Hunter for Improved Investigation Capability
- Cyber Risk Institute Expands Its Profile
- Digital Politics: The Future of Voting Technology
- Ethics in Electronics
- The Cyber Bad Guys Are Getting Worse
- A First Look at the Google Antitrust Suit
- The Pause
- Cybersecurity Incidents of the Summer
- The Changing Digital Economy and Cyber Risks
- The Future of U.S. Manufacturing
- Tech CEO Summer Superbowl hearing
- Technology & Privacy Alert
- This Week
- A Remembrance of Tommy Raskin
- A New Year’s Resolution
- Over the River and Through The Woods
- Dropping the Mic
- Won’t You Be My Neighbor?
- The Cyber Bad Guys Are Getting Worse
- What We Hear
- Track of Time
- Video: Conversations with American Legends
- Conversations with American Legends
- A New Era of Insurance Marketing
- American Legend